Skip to main content
Dads Who Care

Free guide

What are the risks of going to family court?

A practical guide to the risks of family court, including findings of fact, contact changes, costs, delay and Cafcass influence.

10 min read · Reviewed 3 September 2026

What are the risks of going to family court?

Family court can be the right decision. It can also cost more, take longer and change your relationship with your child in ways you did not expect. This guide explains the main risks, and why court is sometimes still necessary.

The answer in 30 seconds

Before you ask the family court to decide arrangements for your child, you should understand that:

  • you lose control of the outcome, and the court can order something neither parent asked for;
  • the court can decide that an allegation against you is true without the kind of proof you might expect, and that decision then shapes the rest of the case;
  • if abuse is alleged, be prepared for Cafcass to recommend no direct contact with your child, before anything has been proved;
  • it can become expensive, sometimes very expensive;
  • one parent may have a funded lawyer while the other does not;
  • it usually takes months, and sometimes years;
  • you can lose time with your child that you cannot get back;
  • Cafcass and other professionals can strongly influence what happens, and their reports can contain mistakes that are hard to correct;
  • it is hard on your health, and it affects your child.

None of this means you should not apply. Sometimes there is no realistic alternative. It means you should understand what you are taking on first.

Costs, hearings and the court process are covered in more detail in separate guides.

1. You lose control of the outcome

Before you apply, you decide what to ask for. After you apply, the court decides.

You might ask for equal time. The other parent might ask for no contact. The court can choose neither and order something different again.

The court is not trying to give either parent what they want. It has to decide what is best for the child. That can mean an order that neither parent is happy with.

Starting a case is also easier than stopping one. Once proceedings have begun, you cannot assume that withdrawing your application will immediately end the court's involvement. The court still has to think about the child's welfare and the stage the case has reached.

2. A finding of fact can be made against you

If the other parent makes allegations and you dispute them, the court may hold a separate hearing to decide whether particular things happened. This is called a fact-finding hearing.

You need to understand how that decision is made.

  • The parent making the allegation has to prove it. The test is the balance of probabilities: the court decides what it thinks is more likely than not to have happened. It does not have to be sure. This is a lower level of proof than a criminal court, which has to be sure before it convicts someone.
  • The court decides that something either did or did not happen. There is no in-between finding.
  • The same legal test applies however serious the allegation: more likely than not. There is no higher standard of proof for a serious allegation. The court still has to weigh all of the evidence carefully, and how likely or unlikely the alleged event is can be part of that.
  • The court does not need a police charge or conviction, a medical record, a photograph or an independent witness. It can prefer one parent's account over the other's.
  • Family judges have wide responsibility for deciding which evidence to accept, what weight to give it and which account is more persuasive.
  • Where controlling or coercive behaviour is alleged, the court looks at the overall pattern, not only single incidents.

This means a finding can be made against you even where you strongly deny the allegation and believe the evidence points the other way.

Courts can also get factual decisions wrong.

Once a finding is made, the rest of the case normally proceeds on the basis that it is true, unless you successfully challenge it. A finding can affect the Cafcass assessment, how risk is judged, whether your contact is supervised, what work or programmes you are expected to complete, and the final decision about your child. Some of that work can be difficult to arrange.

A family court finding is not a criminal conviction. It does not give you a criminal record. But inside your case it is treated as an established fact.

Challenging a finding is hard. Appealing is not a second attempt at the same hearing. An appeal is normally a review of the original decision. An appeal court will not change a factual finding simply because another judge might have reached a different conclusion. You normally have to show that the decision was wrong, or that there was a serious problem with how the hearing was run, and you usually need permission to appeal at all.

3. Your time with your child can change before allegations are decided

If domestic abuse is alleged, you should be prepared for Cafcass to recommend no direct contact with your child.

The allegation does not need to have been proved first. A recommendation like this can come early, before the court has decided whether anything that has been alleged is true.

Do not assume that supervised contact will automatically be offered instead. Sometimes it is, but you should not count on it.

The practical result can be that you stop seeing your child while the case continues. Serious allegations that are disputed can take many months to resolve, and your contact may not return to what it was until they are.

Cafcass does not make the final court order. The judge or magistrates do. But you should not go into proceedings expecting the court simply to reject a Cafcass recommendation. A Cafcass recommendation can have a major influence on what the court orders. If no direct contact is recommended, be prepared for the possibility that you will not see your child directly while the case continues.

Practice Direction 12J is the set of rules the family court follows when abuse is alleged. It requires the court to think carefully about risk before making any temporary arrangement. There is no fixed rule that produces the same outcome in every case, but where serious allegations are disputed and unresolved, restrictions on your contact can be heavy and can last for months.

Fathers who have shared their experience with Dads Who Care describe this as one of the hardest parts of the process, especially when they deny the allegation and had been seeing their child regularly until then.

4. Court can become extremely expensive

To apply for a child arrangements order you currently pay a court fee of £270. If you are on a low income or certain benefits, you may pay less or nothing through the Help with Fees scheme. Official fees change, so check GOV.UK before you apply.

The court fee is usually the smallest part of the cost. The larger costs are things like:

  • solicitors and barristers;
  • preparing statements and organising evidence;
  • expert assessments, if the court orders one;
  • supervised contact sessions;
  • travel, and time away from work.

Costs tend to rise each time the court asks for more evidence or lists another hearing. A case that starts with a manageable estimate can become much more expensive if allegations are made, a fact-finding hearing is needed, or the case runs to a final hearing.

In heavily contested cases, private legal costs can reach tens of thousands of pounds. A long and complex case can move into six figures. Cases costing hundreds of thousands of pounds do happen, but they are exceptional.

In private children cases, each parent usually pays their own costs. Do not assume that disproving an allegation means the other parent will pay your legal bills. That is not the normal outcome.

Our separate guide, How much will family court cost me?, explains how the costs build up.

5. Funding can become seriously unequal

One parent may be able to get legal aid for a children case while the other cannot.

Legal aid for a private children case is usually only available if you can show domestic abuse or a risk to a child, and you also pass a means test, based on your income and savings, and a merits test, based on the strength of your case.

The evidence that opens the door does not have to be proof that the abuse happened. The family court does not have to have decided whether the allegation is true. The accepted forms of evidence are set out in the legal aid rules and include, for example, a letter from a domestic abuse support organisation, a letter from a health professional, a caution, or an ongoing criminal case that has not been decided. The old 60-month time limit that applied to certain forms of evidence was removed in 2017.

So one parent can have publicly funded legal representation while the disputed allegations are still unresolved. The other parent, accused but not funded, may be paying a solicitor from savings, borrowing money, or representing themselves.

This imbalance can exist from an early stage in the case, before anything has been decided.

6. Your case may take a long time

Ministry of Justice figures for January to March 2026 show that private children cases took an average of 35 weeks to conclude.

An average is not a maximum. Many cases finish faster. In the same period, 52 percent of private law cases were dealt with within 26 weeks. But at the end of March 2026, 1,692 private law cases had been running for 100 weeks or more, which is close to two years.

Disputed allegations, reports, expert evidence, programmes, adjourned hearings or an appeal can all make a case longer.

Your own case may be shorter or longer than the average. Do not plan your life on the assumption that everything will be resolved at the first hearing. These figures are updated every three months.

7. You may lose an important part of your child's life

A case takes place over months. Your child keeps growing during that time.

A long period of reduced, supervised or stopped contact can mean missing birthdays, school events, holidays, everyday routines and important stages in your child's development.

A later order cannot give that time back. The court may restore or increase contact, but the relationship may then have to be rebuilt slowly.

This is one of the most serious effects of delay.

8. Cafcass recommendations can have a major influence

Cafcass is a public body. Its Family Court Advisers carry out safeguarding checks, speak to parents and sometimes children, prepare reports and make recommendations to the court.

Cafcass does not make the final order. The judge or magistrates do. But a Cafcass recommendation can have a major influence on what the court orders, and you should not assume that persuading the court to take a different view will be straightforward.

That makes it worth knowing what people who have dealt with Cafcass say about it, and what the official inspections say. They point in very different directions.

Public reviews. On Trustpilot, accessed on 3 September 2026, Cafcass had a score of 1.1 out of 5 from 1,515 reviews, with 97 percent of them at one star. Not every family who deals with Cafcass leaves a Trustpilot review, so the score cannot tell us exactly what proportion of all families are unhappy. But 1,515 reviews, with 97 percent at one star, are still a large amount of very negative public feedback. The reviews repeatedly mention not being listened to, inaccurate reports, one parent being believed over the other, and evidence not being considered.

If you were choosing a dentist, mechanic or hotel, a rating close to one star would probably make you stop and ask questions. With Cafcass, you usually do not have the same choice about whether they become involved. That makes it especially important to understand their role, read their reports carefully and keep accurate records.

Research. In 2024, researchers published a survey of 511 people who had experience of Cafcass. Most of them were women. It found high levels of dissatisfaction with fairness, openness, accurate reporting and objectivity, and 82 percent of those who answered believed Cafcass had shown bias. The people who took part chose to do so, so the survey cannot tell us what percentage of all Cafcass families feel this way. It does show that hundreds of people reported the same serious concerns.

Official inspection. Ofsted inspects Cafcass. In its 2024 national inspection it rated Cafcass Outstanding in every area it looked at. In a follow-up visit in October 2025, focused on private law cases involving domestic abuse, Ofsted said practice had strengthened since 2024 but was not yet consistent across all parts of the service, and that demand was outstripping the number of available advisers in some areas.

These sources measure different things, and they paint very different pictures. Official inspection findings are largely positive. Public and lived-experience feedback is far more negative. You may find your own experience matches either picture. Either way, it is sensible to read every Cafcass report carefully, check names, dates and facts, keep your own records, and raise anything important that is wrong calmly and in writing.

9. Reports and assessments may contain mistakes or disputed conclusions

A report can contain a plain factual error, such as a wrong date, a wrong account of what you said, or an out of date fact about the other parent's household.

It can also contain a conclusion you disagree with, where the professional has formed a different opinion from yours based on the same information. These are not the same thing, and it helps to keep them separate.

If you believe a report contains a factual error, you can raise it with the professional and with the court. Getting an error accepted and corrected can be difficult. The professional may disagree that it is an error, may treat it as minor, or may say it does not change the recommendation. Even when you can show that your correction was received, the report may stay the same.

Raise material errors, do it calmly, and do it in writing, so there is a clear record. Our member guides on Cafcass go into this in much more detail.

10. The process can affect your health

Long proceedings can take over daily life. Reading documents, preparing statements, finding money and worrying about contact can affect your sleep, concentration, work and relationships. Some parents describe anxiety, low mood, physical illness, isolation and a lasting loss of confidence, and the effect can continue after the final hearing.

If you are already struggling with your mental or physical health, be honest with yourself about that before you apply, and try to get support in place. Dads Who Care is not a mental health service, but you do not have to go through this with no support.

11. The case can affect your child

Proceedings are about the child, but the process itself can be hard on them.

Depending on the case, a child may experience uncertainty about where they will live, repeated changes to arrangements, tense handovers, questions from several professionals, pressure to take sides, and disruption to relationships with a parent and with wider family.

Not every child experiences all of this, and children are affected in different ways. But a later order cannot undo the time that has passed or remove every effect of a long, tense dispute.

12. Why court may still be the right choice

After all of that, court can still be necessary.

Sometimes there is no realistic alternative. For example:

  • the other parent will not respond, will not go to mediation, or will not stick to anything that is agreed;
  • contact has stopped completely and nothing you try outside court changes it;
  • there are genuine safeguarding concerns that a court needs to look at properly;
  • an important decision, such as schooling or medical treatment, cannot be agreed;
  • the other parent is threatening to move away with your child, or has already done so;
  • there is an order in place and it is being ignored;
  • mediation is not safe or not suitable.

A court order can also protect and steady a child's relationship with a parent. A clear order that is followed can end months of uncertainty.

Court has real risks. Court can also be necessary. Both of those things are true. This guide cannot tell you whether to apply in your situation. It is meant to help you go in with your eyes open.

Summary

Going to family court can mean:

  • you give up control of the outcome;
  • a finding of fact can be made against you and is hard to undo;
  • your time with your child can change before allegations are decided;
  • it can be expensive, and funding is often unequal;
  • it usually takes months and can take years;
  • you can lose time with your child that you cannot get back;
  • professional recommendations carry weight, and reports can contain mistakes that are hard to correct;
  • it is hard on you and on your child.

And despite all of that, it is sometimes the only way to protect your relationship with your child.

Understand the risks. Then decide.

What happens next?

Continue to How much will family court cost me?

If you want to work through this decision step by step, the I'm thinking about going to court Learning Journey covers what to try first, what the court can and cannot do, and how to prepare an application.

Sources

Disclaimer

This guide provides general educational information for parents in England and Wales. It is not legal advice. The facts, risks and possible outcomes are different in every case. Follow every court order, police condition and safeguarding requirement that applies to you.

Sources and references

This guide is for general education only and is not legal advice. Read our full disclaimer.

Related free guides

All free guidesMembership and pricing